Grounded in North Babylon.
Growing with every
family we serve.

Paul built The Della Agency on the same values his father instilled in him growing up in North Babylon: honesty, hard work, and always looking out for your neighbors. His father was a trusted local insurance agent here, and that legacy is felt in everything the agency does today.

Today, The Della Agency is an award-winning Allstate insurance agency serving families and businesses across New York and 11 states. Paul leads a dedicated, people-first team that ensures every client receives clear guidance, reliable protection, and genuine care — not policy numbers and form letters.

Whether you're a first-time homeowner in North Babylon, a business owner in Bay Shore, or a family in Deer Park looking to bundle and save — Paul and his team understand the specific insurance needs of Long Island families. From flood risks to homeowners coverage on the South Shore, we know this area because we live here too.

Despite growing to a second office in Falls Church, VA, Paul remains deeply rooted in North Babylon — actively supporting local causes, youth programs, and community initiatives. When you're a client at The Della Agency, you're supporting a business that genuinely gives back to the neighborhood you call home.

Call, stop in, or get a free quote online. Our office at 1135 Deer Park Ave is open Monday–Friday 9 AM–6 PM and Saturdays 10 AM–1 PM. No pressure, no jargon — just straight answers from a neighbor who's been doing this his whole life.